Insecure Writer's Support Group is a blog hop hosted by Alex J. Cavanaugh where totally insecure writers can get together and share the things that are making us go argh!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
This week I want to talk about inevitable comparisons between books. Or more specifically, my upcoming book Seeder's Poison and The Hunger Games (THG).
Now that I’ve sent my little MS out into the world for critiquing, I’m
getting a bit of feedback which likens my story to The Hunger Games. Someone even told me they're too similar to even bother publishing my MS. So before I ditch my story altogether, I wanted to share this insecurity with you guys and see if you've had similar problems.
I
won’t deny the similarities between my MS and THG: an all-powerful and controlling government
situated in a central area, an oppressed populace that’s divided into sections, a
strong heroine who is handy with a bow and knows plants inside out. But there are things which are
different as well. No love triangle for one. No games for another. Definitely no themes on the hazards of war (at least I hope not).
Regardless of what I say, comparisons will be made whether I like it or not. After all, there are many claims that The Hunger Games is based on Battle Royale by Koushun Takami and Lord of the Flies by William Golding. Heck, when I described the plot of THG to my husband when we were contemplating watching the movie, he said, "That's the plot of every Final Fantasy game I've ever played."
Besides, if there's any book my novel could be compared with, The Hunger Games isn't too shabby at all. It's just that I'm a picky reader and I know that I haven't picked up books because they've been compared to other more popular stories that I've read. Half-Blood by Jennifer L. Armentrout (too close to Vampire Academy) and Carrier of the Mark by Leigh Fallon (too close to Twilight..although admittedly I didn't like Twilight) to name a few. And if I could go back and remove the things which are similar I would. It's just that I can't do so without losing the the central theme of my MS.
Also, the second book in the series will deviate from what makes my book so similar to THG, but now I'm not sure if I should even worry about writing the next book if no one is going to read the first book anyway. What are your thoughts guys? Would you read a book that's too similar to something else that's popular?
Showing posts with label The Hunger Games. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Hunger Games. Show all posts
Tuesday, 5 June 2012
Saturday, 31 March 2012
Saturday, 24 March 2012
Hunger Games/Dystopian Celebration Giveaway!!
To celebrate the movies release and spotlight other dystopican books, I'm going to be giving away to one lucky winner, a book from the below list:
The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins (For you crazy people who haven't read it!)
Under The Never Sky by Veronica Rossi
Partials by Dan Wells
Obernewtyn by Isobelle Carmody
Article 5 by Kristen Simmons
Legend by Marie Lu
Tomorrow When The War Began by John Marsden
Divergent by Veronica Roth
Angelfall by Susan Ee (Purchased from Createspace)
Enclave by Ann Aguirre
Wither by Laura DeStefano
Uglies by Scott Westerfeld
Aside from Angelfall, all other books will be ordered from The Book Depository. I am happy for people to request sequels to any of the books mentioned if they have already read the first books.
Good Luck and may the odds be ever in your favour! (Score one for me for using that in this giveaway!)
Friday, 9 March 2012
Why I Love The Hunger Games By Sherre of Beckoned By Books

As much as I like to rant about The Hunger Games, it's pretty clear that I love the entire franchise to death. I talk about it incessantly and try to
I’m so glad to be doing a guest post for
Lan’s blog. I stalk her blog often as she’s probably figured out already. Guess
what? The Hunger games movie will be out this month and I am beyond super
excited. I’ve already purchased tickets to the 12:01 movie show time, and now
I’m just bouncing up and down, watching the calendar, and the clock to figure
out how much time is left. The boyfriend told me I was an idiot who needs to do
something else with my time, so I thought the best way would be for me to let you
all know how I began my fan girl obsessive lust for all things Hunger Games.
(That’s probably not what he meant when he told me to do something else, but
whatever)
It began after my high from reading
Twilight for the third time in a row. I needed something good. Something that
made the world around me disappear and the adrenaline rush in my veins.
Something that made my heart quicken and my emotions go into overdrive. I
picked up a few books at Borders (May you Rest in Peace my Beloved Borders
Books) and they all sucked. Like all of them. At this point I was giving The
Hunger Games series the cold shoulder. Yeah, I read the synopsis, but I
couldn’t bring myself to read the book. It looked too boring, to young, too
depressing. Besides, there could never be a book that will make me feel as
alive as Twilight, I was sure of it. Then, something happened.
I was surfing the internet acting like a
total Twilight groupie when I came upon a Hunger Games review. “Let’s see if
the book sucks as much as I think it should,” I said to myself. I read the
review that discussed the awesomeness that was THG and thought, well maybe
she’s biased. There’s no way this book can actually be that good. So I read
another review and more and finally I got literally upset! These people have no
idea what they’re talking about. The Hunger Games has to suck. Look at that
cover. It’s so boring. That stupid bird in a circle, what’s that supposed to
mean? They’re spending time going bird hunting or something? Oh and let’s not get started on the synopsis.
Kid’s fighting to the death on TV? Talk about depressing! Maybe they’re all
getting paid to do the reviews. Yea, that’s probably it. I’ll just go out and
buy the book and read the horribleness and THEN I’ll be able to tell everyone
that they’re total liars and the book sucks.
It just so happened that it was December of
2010 so Christmas was coming up. I told my mom to buy the whole series for me
along with some other books and she painstakingly obliged (she made the mistake
of telling me as a child that as long as I read, she would buy me as many books
as I want….talk about a bad idea. You should see my stacks of books) Any who,
when I got it, I started reading………..and reading………..and
reading……………………………..and was finished the entire book in 9 hours straight. No
food, no cellphone interruptions, no breaks of any kind. People came and talked
AT me, I think. I never paid attention.
I remember walking around with my book when
I heard the doorbell ring, opening it, and letting someone in. It was a family
member, I think. It could have been a stranger though, I’d have never known.
The book was amazing. SUPER, FANTASTIC, SUPERB, EXCITING, OH MY #(*^@&!
GOSH HOW ON EARTH DID I LIVE WITHOUT YOU SO LONG, I LOVE YOU SO MUCH, PLEASE
NEVER LEAVE ME, I LOVE YOU, WILL YOU MARRY ME, ID FOLLOW YOU ANYWHERE OH MY
GOODNESS OH MY GOODNESS OH MY GOODNESS AHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!
It gave me the feelings
I wanted and more, but, like an obsessive junkie, I wanted more!!!! I needed
more!!! So then I got the audio books. I listened to them in the car, and in my
iPod over and over. (Everyone hated riding in the car with me) I started to
tell random people about the awesomeness that was THG. I started incorporating
random HG lingo into my daily life – “I want to show them that they don’t own
me. If I’m going to go to work, I want it to be on my terms. I want to show
them that I’m just not another employee in their company,” “Remember boyfriend,
we’re madly in love, so it’s ok to kiss me whenever you want,” “Do well on your
test little sister, and may the odds be ever in your favor.” (That’s my
favorite one, because she tended to look at me and roll her eyes as if I was
crazy)The rest is history. I began consuming more and more books, but Twilight,
and Hunger Games will always be my favorites (not necessarily in that order). A
few other books have joined their ranks in my mind, Telesa, The Mortal
Instruments Series and a few others, but Twilight and the Hunger Games have,
and always will hold a very special, lust-filled, obsessive place in my heart.
~ Thank you so much Sherre for taking the time to write up this post. Obsession really does love company because I found myself nodding to so many of the things you said. I remember not wanting to read The Hunger Games because of all the hype and because so many people were saying how graphic the killing is. I'm glad (and also a bit disturbed) that the violence didn't phase me because I would have missed out of one of the best book I've ever read.
On that note, I'd like to invite all you guys to share your stories about when and how you decided to read The Hunger Games. Was it on your WoW lists? Or did you just stumble upon it? I came into the phenomenon very late so I wasn't around for the original hoopla. Would love to recapture that now!
~ Thank you so much Sherre for taking the time to write up this post. Obsession really does love company because I found myself nodding to so many of the things you said. I remember not wanting to read The Hunger Games because of all the hype and because so many people were saying how graphic the killing is. I'm glad (and also a bit disturbed) that the violence didn't phase me because I would have missed out of one of the best book I've ever read.
On that note, I'd like to invite all you guys to share your stories about when and how you decided to read The Hunger Games. Was it on your WoW lists? Or did you just stumble upon it? I came into the phenomenon very late so I wasn't around for the original hoopla. Would love to recapture that now!
Wednesday, 7 March 2012
Insecure Writers Support Group #1: Licence To Kill
Insecure Writer's Support Group is a blog hop hosted by Alex J. Cavanaugh where us totally insecure writers can get together and share the things that are making us go argh!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Hmm...where to even start this month. I suppose that given this is meant to be my The Hunger Games appreciation month, I'll talk about a theme that has been bugging me on my writing journey for a while now. The concept of YA books (in my case YA dystopian more specifically) and killing people/things.
You all know I worship the genius that is Katniss Everdeen (I choose to ignore everything that happened in Mockingjay) but sometimes, when I have my super critical book reviewer pants on, I start to wonder about how unrealistic it is that Katniss doesn't ever go on the offensive unless she's given no choice. Kathy from Read This Instead and I had a brief discussion about this and it's got me wondering whether or not readers would be much less sympathetic to a character if they dispensed with the goody two-shoes and went out for blood.
Even Peeta and Gale could be considered plot devices to support this idea (Peeta being Mr Con and Gale being Mr Pro). And readers seem to have responded in a way which suggests that they'd rather not have their heroes taking out the bad guys Terminator style.Everywhere I look, it's Team Peeta all the way.
Sadly, I am not in this majority reader group and I'm worried that this will trickle down to my own characters and they'll end up being hated for their offensiveness. Maybe it's because I'm much more A than YA these days. Maybe I've been brainwashed by the insane amount of action movies I watch and I'm desensitized to violence. Perhaps as a second generation child of war, I just don't buy the whole stand up for yourself but don't get your hands bloody stance.
Then there's the whole confusing grey area that is YA paranormal where it's okay to have the heroes kill as many vampires/werewolves/angels as possible but as soon as they harm a human (no matter how badly the human deserves it) it's all "you shouldn't have done that."
So help me out guys. Which camp do you belong to? Does it disturb you when an MC takes matters into their own hands? Or do you prefer to keep it clean?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)